The Globe and Mail finally provides some historical perspective to the prejudice-tinged discourse about the passengers aboard the MV Sun Sea:
Canada’s first boat people were the Norse who came ashore a thousand years ago in Newfoundland. They fit the refugee pattern: farmers and simple artisans, maybe a few fierce Vikings among them known for terrorizing Europe, people driven out of their homeland by population pressures and political unrest…
The primal fear of the stranger, the Other, seems edgiest when they arrive by sea.
They can be watched, coming across the blank, huge canvas of the ocean, moment by moment growing larger and more ominous on the horizon, carrying alien stuff. Hence the noisy narrative of the MV Sun Sea’s progress over the Pacific into Canadian territory with its Tamil cargo.
Reports indicate that the 500-odd passengers are Sri Lankan Tamils, with some analysts connecting them to the terrorist-listed LTTE organization. The media has been relatively ineffective at providing wider context for this particular event, and it has remained generally fixated on Canada’s ‘broken’ refugee system which is ‘taken advantage of’ by opportunistic migrants.
This is one of the first articles to mention that boat people have featured in crucial moments in Canada’s history. Canada’s rejection of the MS St. Louis, carrying 907 German Jewish refugees in 1939, remains a moment of enduring national shame: many of those turned away died in Hitler’s gas chambers. By contrast, the open welcome offered to tens of thousands of Vietnamese boat people in the 1970s and 1980s has been a social and economic boon for Canada.
The problem is not Canada’s refugee system. The problem is an approach to migration policy informed by the belief that we can globalize everything except for human mobility. No matter how many detention centres or extra border defenses we build, people will continue to come. We must look at the issue of migration through the lens of global interdependence, where movement is arises out of greater social and economic integration. It is an irrepressible impulse that will continue to intensify in the coming century.
The essential questions are not How do we stop people coming? or How do we toughen our migration policies? They are: How do we create systems that accommodate cross-border mobility? How do we mobilise social institutions to support migrants? How do we harness the aspirations and ambitions of migrants for the common good?
The answers to these questions will help us to show greater hospitality towards those who cross great oceans to join Canadian society.